Master's Thesis - Preface

Preface: Scope and Outline of this Work

This work retrieves an all but forgotten history--that of a wartime program of social welfare benefits operated by the U.S. Social Security Board during World War II, as part of the government's program of forced relocation and internment of thousands of U.S. residents whose ethnic or racial origins lay in the countries of the Axis powers. This program provided welfare benefits to some of those adversely affected by the wartime exclusions and internments.

During World War II, almost 130,000 U.S. residents of Japanese ancestry were forcibly relocated from their homes by agencies of the federal government and interned in government-run facilities around the country. In addition to the Japanese affected by these "restrictive governmental actions," more than 14,000 persons of either German or Italian ancestry were also interned, and many thousands of U.S. residents from all three groups were subjected to various restrictions on their movements, and loss of other civil liberties. (1)

Most of this history is well-known. What has been almost entirely overlooked in prior scholarship is that in the midst of this highly repressive governmental action, other agencies of the federal government were engaged in what can only be described as humanitarian efforts to lessen some of the practical burdens of the internments. In particular, the U.S. Social Security Board (2) played a largely unseen role in providing both cash and in-kind assistance and other services to internees under a program known as Assistance and Services to Enemy Aliens and Others (ASEAO). (3) Moreover, as will emerge from a review of the documentary record, in several policy areas, the Social Security Board implemented remarkably generous policies (given the context in which the ASEAO program arose) based on the premise that the internees were to be accorded, as far as possible, the same rights as any other beneficiary of 1940s-era social welfare programs.

The ASEAO program, authorized in a broad way by President Roosevelt via executive fiat, was thus an unusual example of a compensatory social welfare program in the context of the decidedly repressive activities of the wartime internments. We might even say of it, that the ASEAO program was an island of compassionate government policy within the larger sea of repression and loss of civil liberties of the wartime internments.

The object of the present work is to restore our awareness of this internment-related program; to explain its principles and operations; and to analyze it in some depth as an example of federal social welfare policymaking in this highly unusual context during this remarkable episode in America's history.




1. The internments discussed in this thesis involved persons of Japanese, German and Italian descent. Some of these persons were naturalized American citizens, some were native-born American citizens, others were resident aliens lawfully admitted to the U.S. for permanent residence who were still citizens of their countries of origin. All were united only in the fact that their ancestries lay in the three nations of the Axis powers. For purposes of this study, these distinctions in residency status will not generally be pertinent. Thus, for convenience sake, I will tend to lump together these various categories in generic labels, unless I have a specific point to make that necessitates a finer distinction.

2. The U.S. Social Security Board was part of the sub-cabinet Federal Security Agency (FSA). In addition to Social Security, FSA had responsibility for the Public Health Service, the Food and Drug Administration, the Office of Education, and a handful of other miscellaneous functions of the federal government.

3. There were several shifts in nomenclature in this program during the course of the war. "Assistance and Services to Enemy Aliens" is how the program was initially known, but when citizens became eligible for coverage "Others" was added and the acronym juggled to become ASEAO. Sometimes the ASEAO program is referred to as "Services and Assistance to Enemy Aliens and Others Affected by Restrictive Governmental Action"; sometimes only by the short-hand of EA, for Enemy Aliens. I will use ASEAO throughout for convenience.

The archival records of this program are housed in the National Archives in College Park, Maryland, as part of Record Group 47. The documents related to the ASEAO program are concentrated in the files of the Bureau of Public Assistance, and consist of 35 "records center" sized boxes of material. I have previously co-authored and published an online Guide to the textual holdings of RG-47: Larry DeWitt and Kristen Taynor, Social Security: Textual Records in the National Archives II, (U. S. Government document, August 2003). The Guide provides a box-level listing, with locations, of the records of the ASEAO program. The Guide can be found on the website of the U.S. Social Security Administration at: http://www.ssa.gov/history/archives/nara/NARAGuide.htm

This research has uncovered only one detailed published account of the ASEAO program, a contemporary report by a government official: Margaret Leahy, "Public Assistance For Restricted Persons During The Second World War," The Social Services Review, Vol. XIX, No. 1, March 1945. There is a brief, inadequate, chapter on the program in Stephen Fox, The Unknown Internment: An Oral History of the Relocation of Italian Americans during World War II, (Boston, Twayne Publishers, 1990), 140-150. There is also the barest of mentions in Audrie Girdner and Anne Loftis, The Great Betrayal: The Evacuation of the Japanese-Americans During World War II, (New York, Macmillan Co., 1969), 106.